Nine of Ten MLB Award Winners Ranked First or Second on BBMI's Boards
Seven winners were first on their boards, including both MVPs, both Cy Youngs and both relievers. Two were second. The tenth, Sal Stewart, was 13th.
BBMI's final 2026 award boards had seven of the ten eventual winners ranked first. Two more winners ranked second. The exception was Cincinnati's Sal Stewart, who won National League Rookie of the Year from 13th on BBMI's board.
The boards rank regular-season production through September 27. They do not forecast a vote. The Baseball Writers' Association of America (BBWAA) decides the awards, 30 ballots per league, submitted before the postseason. Putting the two side by side shows where a value model and the voters saw the season the same way, and where they did not.
Final regular-season value rankings compared with BBWAA results. The rankings are not forecasts of the vote.
The scorecard
| Award | BBMI leader | BBWAA winner | Winner's BBMI rank |
|---|---|---|---|
| AL MVP | Yordan Alvarez | Yordan Alvarez Match | 1 |
| NL MVP | Pete Crow-Armstrong | Pete Crow-Armstrong Match | 1 |
| AL Cy Young | Cam Schlittler | Cam Schlittler Match | 1 |
| NL Cy Young | Jacob Misiorowski | Jacob Misiorowski Match | 1 |
| AL Reliever | Louis Varland | Louis Varland Match | 1 |
| NL Reliever | Mason Miller | Mason Miller Match | 1 |
| AL Rookie | Parker Messick | Kevin McGonigle | 2 |
| NL Rookie | Nolan McLean | Sal Stewart | 13 |
| AL Manager | Kevin Cash | Will Venable | 2 |
| NL Manager | Pat Murphy | Pat Murphy Match | 1 |
BBMI leader is the top-ranked candidate on BBMI's final board for that award. The reliever rows are the BBWAA's new Reliever of the Year award. Bryan Baker, third on BBMI's AL board, won the separate Mariano Rivera award, which is voted by former relievers.
One piece of context belongs next to the seven. Five of those matches were unanimous votes. In the four races where the winner drew 20 or fewer of the 30 first-place votes, BBMI's leader won two.
Full results: finalists, vote totals and BBMI values for all ten awards
How to read these tables. Value and runs saved are in runs above replacement, defined in the Method section; an everyday player who hits at the average of regulars over 600 plate appearances is worth about 18 runs before position and defense, a league-average starter over 180 innings about 18, and roughly ten runs equal one win. Vote points are BBWAA totals, with order of finish in parentheses. Maximums: 420 for MVP, 210 for Cy Young, reliever and rookie, 150 for manager. Finalists are the top three in the voting.
Most Valuable Player
| BBMI | Player | Value | Vote pts |
|---|---|---|---|
| 1 | Yordan Alvarez, HOU Won | 71.1 | 420 (1st) |
| 2 | Bobby Witt Jr., KC Finalist | 66.9 | 188 (3rd) |
| 3 | Junior Caminero, TB Finalist | 49.9 | 267 (2nd) |
| 4 | Kevin McGonigle, DET | 48.4 | 109 (7th) |
| 5 | Miguel Vargas, CWS | 43.2 | 129 (6th) |
| BBMI | Player | Value | Vote pts |
|---|---|---|---|
| 1 | Pete Crow-Armstrong, CHC Won | 105.1 | 420 (1st) |
| 2 | Shohei Ohtani, LAD Finalist | 67.5 | 264 (2nd) |
| 3 | Elly De La Cruz, CIN | 65.7 | 173 (4th) |
| 4 | Brice Turang, MIL Finalist | 57.9 | 190 (3rd) |
| 5 | Gabriel Moreno, ARI | 52.5 | 132 (6th) |
Cy Young
| BBMI | Pitcher | Runs saved | Vote pts |
|---|---|---|---|
| 1 | Cam Schlittler, NYY Won | 64.7 | 210 (1st) |
| 2 | Parker Messick, CLE Finalist | 56.8 | 84 (3rd) |
| 3 | Sonny Gray, BOS | 51.5 | 21 (5th) |
| 4 | Drew Rasmussen, TB | 50.4 | 72 (4th) |
| 5 | Dylan Cease, TOR Finalist | 48.3 | 110 (2nd) |
| BBMI | Pitcher | Runs saved | Vote pts |
|---|---|---|---|
| 1 | Jacob Misiorowski, MIL Won | 61.2 | 210 (1st) |
| 2 | Yoshinobu Yamamoto, LAD | 56.2 | 63 (4th) |
| 3 | Cristopher Sánchez, PHI Finalist | 55.4 | 99 (2nd) |
| 4 | Chris Sale, ATL Finalist | 54.4 | 98 (3rd) |
| 5 | Eduardo Rodriguez, ARI | 47.7 | 2 (7th) |
Reliever of the Year
| BBMI | Reliever | Value | Vote pts |
|---|---|---|---|
| 1 | Louis Varland, TOR Won | 27.4 | 146 (1st) |
| 2 | Brent Headrick, NYY | 27.1 | 12 (8th) |
| 3 | Bryan Baker, TB Finalist | 25.6 | 111 (3rd) |
| 4 | Cade Smith, CLE Finalist | 25.3 | 133 (2nd) |
| 5 | Kevin Kelly, TB | 21.5 | 0 |
| BBMI | Reliever | Value | Vote pts |
|---|---|---|---|
| 1 | Mason Miller, SD Won | 25.3 | 210 (1st) |
| 2 | Yuki Matsui, SD | 23.9 | 0 |
| 3 | Jhoan Duran, PHI Finalist | 22.8 | 110 (2nd) |
| 4 | Abner Uribe, MIL | 22.3 | 2 |
| 5 | Juan Morillo, ARI | 21.1 | 0 |
Relief value covers pitchers with zero starts and at least 30 innings. It counts runs prevented and innings, not saves. Trevor Megill, third in the NL vote with 66 points, is outside BBMI's top ten.
AL Rookie of the Year
| BBMI | Player | Value | Vote pts |
|---|---|---|---|
| 1 | Parker Messick, CLE Finalist | 56.8 | 122 (2nd) |
| 2 | Kevin McGonigle, DET Won | 48.4 | 204 (1st) |
| 3 | Payton Tolle, BOS Finalist | 36.2 | 54 (3rd) |
| 4 | Walbert Ureña, LAA | 32.9 | 2 |
| 5 | Carter Jensen, KC | 30.7 | 31 (5th) |
Manager of the Year
| BBMI | Manager | Record | Wins above Talent | Vote pts |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| 1 | Kevin Cash, TB Finalist | 98-64 | +7.0 | 98 |
| 2 | Will Venable, CWS Won | 84-78 | +5.2 | 111 |
| 3 | Derek Shelton, MIN | 77-85 | +3.2 | 0 |
| 4 | Stephen Vogt, CLE | 85-77 | +2.7 | 9 |
| 8 | Chad Tracy, BOS Finalist | 77-58 | −2.0 | 47 |
| BBMI | Manager | Record | Wins above Talent | Vote pts |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| 1 | Pat Murphy, MIL Won | 103-59 | +8.8 | 124 |
| 2 | Don Mattingly, PHI Finalist | 79-55 | +7.3 | 25 |
| 3 | Terry Francona, CIN | 75-87 | +6.1 | 0 |
| 4 | Walt Weiss, ATL Finalist | 94-68 | +5.5 | 86 |
| 10 | Craig Stammen, SD | 91-71 | +4.1 | 24 |
Wins above Talent is actual wins minus Talent times games managed. Talent is BBMI's rating of a club's full-strength roster as an expected winning percentage; .500 is a league-average roster. Record is under that manager only. Rows are BBMI's top four plus any other manager who drew at least 20 points. Stephen Vogt is tied for fourth with Baltimore's Craig Albernaz, who received no votes.
Where BBMI and the writers agreed
MVP. Yordan Alvarez and Pete Crow-Armstrong were unanimous, and both were first on BBMI's boards. Crow-Armstrong's 105.1 runs was the highest value on any board, 37.6 ahead of Shohei Ohtani, who was second on both lists. In the AL the board and the ballot named the same top three in a different order. BBMI had Bobby Witt Jr. second, 17.0 runs ahead of Junior Caminero. The writers put Caminero second on 27 of 30 ballots.
Cy Young. Cam Schlittler and Jacob Misiorowski were also unanimous and also first on the boards. The differences came behind them. BBMI ranked Parker Messick second in the AL and Dylan Cease fifth; the writers had Cease second and Messick third. In the NL, BBMI had Yoshinobu Yamamoto second, and the writers placed him fourth.
Reliever. Mason Miller was unanimous in the NL. The AL was the one close vote of the six: Louis Varland 146 points, Cade Smith 133, Bryan Baker 111. BBMI's board had those three within 2.1 runs of each other, with Varland first.
Where they disagreed
NL Rookie of the Year: Sal Stewart
| Player | BBWAA finish | Vote pts | BBMI rank | BBMI value |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Sal Stewart, CIN, 1B | 1st | 170 | 13th | 18.0 |
| Carson Benge, NYM, OF | 2nd | 107 | 4th | 26.4 |
| JJ Wetherholt, STL, 2B | 3rd | 99 | 2nd | 31.8 |
| Nolan McLean, NYM, P | 4th | 70 | 1st | 32.4 |
BBMI value is runs above replacement: park-adjusted batting, a position adjustment, Statcast fielding and baserunning for hitters, and park-adjusted runs saved for pitchers. An everyday player who hits at the average of regulars over 600 plate appearances is worth about 18 runs before position and defense, and roughly ten runs equal one win. BBMI ranked 203 NL rookies. Vote points are on a 7-4-3-2-1 ballot; the maximum is 210.
Stewart hit 32 home runs and drove in 112 while playing all 162 games, and 20 of 30 voters put him first. BBMI ranked him 13th among NL rookies at 18.0 runs.
Three things held his value down. He played 948 innings at first base and 11 games at designated hitter, and the position adjustment charged him 8.7 runs for it. His baserunning cost another 3.7 runs; he was caught stealing 8 times in 23 attempts. His defense also graded below average by Statcast. Home runs and RBI are not inputs on their own.
Other measures point the same direction. Baseball Reference has Stewart at 2.0 wins above replacement, against 4.5 for JJ Wetherholt, and MLB.com's account of the vote called Stewart "a traditionalist's choice."
That supports a lower read on Stewart than the vote gave. It does not establish that 13th is the right rank. The whole range is narrow: 14.4 runs, about a win and a half, separate first from 13th. And seven of the 12 rookies BBMI ranked ahead of him were pitchers. Ranking hitters against pitchers on one list is the least certain comparison a value model makes, and it is where this board and the vote were furthest apart.
AL Rookie of the Year: McGonigle over Messick
The AL race was the same comparison. BBMI and the writers agreed on the top three names. The board had the pitcher first, Parker Messick at 56.8 runs, and the hitter second, Kevin McGonigle at 48.4. The writers gave McGonigle 28 of 30 first-place votes. Baseball Reference is on their side: it credits McGonigle with 7.1 wins above replacement, the most of any AL player.
AL Manager of the Year: Venable over Cash
BBMI's manager measure is wins above Talent: actual wins minus the wins implied by its rating of the roster. Zero means a club won what its roster rated, and this season's managers ranged from +8.8 to −11.9.
Pat Murphy's +8.8 was the highest in either league, and he won the NL award with 20 first-place votes, his third in a row. In the AL the board had Kevin Cash first at +7.0 and Will Venable second at +5.2. The vote had them the other way, 111 points to 98. Venable's White Sox won 84 games a year after losing 102. That 24-win improvement is a case BBMI's measure does not capture, because it compares a club with its current roster rating and not with last season.
The All-MLB comparison
MLB's All-MLB teams are chosen half by fan vote and half by a panel. BBMI fills the same 16 slots per team strictly by value.
BBMI found most of the same players and agreed less often on first team or second. Eleven official first-teamers were on BBMI's first team. The other five were on its second: Pete Alonso, Jackson Chourio, Chris Sale, Dylan Cease and Mason Miller. First base was the thinnest call on the board. Jake Bauers led Alonso by one tenth of a run, and the voters took Alonso, who led the AL with 43 home runs and 113 RBI.
Shohei Ohtani needs a note. He is second on the NL MVP board at 67.5 runs and on neither BBMI All-MLB team. His MVP value combines hitting and pitching. All-MLB slots are filled one role at a time: his 85 2/3 innings were short of the 100 required of a starter, and on hitting alone the board placed him behind Alvarez and Ben Rice at designated hitter. The official teams left him off as well.
See all 32 selections
| Pos. | BBMI first team | Official first team | BBMI second team | Official second team |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| C | Gabriel Moreno, 52.5 | Gabriel Moreno | Drake Baldwin, 33.9 | William Contreras |
| 1B | Jake Bauers, 36.8 | Pete Alonso | Pete Alonso, 36.7 | Willson Contreras |
| 2B | Brice Turang, 57.9 | Brice Turang | Brandon Lowe, 48.2 | Brandon Lowe |
| 3B | Junior Caminero, 49.9 | Junior Caminero | Alex Bregman, 47.0 | Alex Bregman |
| SS | Bobby Witt Jr., 66.9 | Bobby Witt Jr. | Elly De La Cruz, 65.7 | Elly De La Cruz |
| OF | Pete Crow-Armstrong, 105.1 | Pete Crow-Armstrong | James Wood, 42.2 | James Wood |
| OF | Fernando Tatis Jr., 45.1 | Fernando Tatis Jr. | Jackson Chourio, 41.8 | Randy Arozarena |
| OF | Michael Harris II, 45.3 | Jackson Chourio | Seiya Suzuki, 39.8 | Jordan Walker |
| DH | Yordan Alvarez, 71.1 | Yordan Alvarez | Ben Rice, 38.0 | Ben Rice |
| SP | Cam Schlittler, 64.7 | Cam Schlittler | Sonny Gray, 51.5 | Sonny Gray |
| SP | Jacob Misiorowski, 61.2 | Jacob Misiorowski | Drew Rasmussen, 50.4 | Drew Rasmussen |
| SP | Cristopher Sánchez, 55.4 | Cristopher Sánchez | Chris Sale, 54.4 | Yoshinobu Yamamoto |
| SP | Parker Messick, 56.8 | Chris Sale | Dylan Cease, 48.3 | Tarik Skubal |
| SP | Yoshinobu Yamamoto, 56.2 | Dylan Cease | Eduardo Rodriguez, 47.7 | Jesús Luzardo |
| RP | Louis Varland, 27.4 | Louis Varland | Bryan Baker, 25.6 | Bryan Baker |
| RP | Brent Headrick, 27.1 | Mason Miller | Mason Miller, 25.3 | Cade Smith |
Figures are BBMI value in runs above replacement, defined in the Method section. Shaded cells are players BBMI and the official vote placed on the same team. Within a position group the rows are aligned to show matches, not ranked. The seven BBMI selections not chosen for either official team are Jake Bauers, Michael Harris II, Parker Messick, Brent Headrick, Drake Baldwin, Seiya Suzuki and Eduardo Rodriguez. BBMI assigns each player his primary position by games played; hitters need 400 plate appearances, starters 100 innings, relievers 30 innings and zero starts.
What the comparison shows
BBMI's boards were built from regular-season production and frozen at September 27. They were not written to predict ballots, and this comparison keeps the misses next to the matches. Where the writers were unanimous, the boards agreed all five times. Where the vote was split, the boards went two for four. Both rookie awards went to hitters the boards ranked behind pitchers, and that comparison is the part of the model that deserves the closest look before next season's boards.
Method and sources
Player value. Value is runs above replacement, where replacement is the level of a freely available minor-league call-up. Hitters get park-adjusted batting, a position adjustment, Statcast fielding and baserunning. Pitchers get park-adjusted runs saved. The MVP board lists hitters, and Ohtani's figure there includes his pitching. The Cy Young board ranks pitchers by runs saved. Rookie eligibility follows MLB's 2026 rookie pool.
Managers. Wins above Talent is actual wins minus the wins implied by BBMI's Talent rating of the roster over the games that manager managed. It credits or charges the manager for the whole gap, including injuries and luck.
Limits. Catcher blocking and throwing are not in the model. Value is not WAR and will not match Baseball Reference or FanGraphs player for player.
What counts as a match. BBMI's top-ranked candidate winning the BBWAA award. For All-MLB, a selection counts if the player is on either BBMI team.
Data. BBMI boards: 2026 MLB Awards & Statistical Titles, final through September 27 (CSV). How the MVP and Cy Young boards moved during the season: 2026 MLB Award Races. Voting: MLB.com totals for MVP, Cy Young, Rookie of the Year and Manager of the Year; the BBWAA for reliever ballots; ESPN for complete point tallies. All-MLB teams: MLB.com. Rankings and values are model outputs, not betting advice.
Related research
Final 2026 Cy Young Runs-Saved Board: Cam Schlittler and Jacob Misiorowski Finish First
The regular season is complete. Cam Schlittler finishes first in BBMI's American League runs-saved model at 64.7 runs saved, 7.9 ahead of Parker Messick; Jacob Misiorowski leads the National League at 61.2, 5.0 ahead of Yoshinobu Yamamoto. These are BBMI's final model rankings, not a forecast of the writers' vote.
Cam Schlittler 64.7 AL · Jacob Misiorowski 61.2 NL · final regular seasonOct 12 · 3 minAwards · MVPFinal 2026 MVP Value Board: Yordan Alvarez and Pete Crow-Armstrong Finish First
The regular season is complete. Yordan Alvarez finishes first in BBMI's American League value model at 71.1 value runs, 4.2 ahead of Bobby Witt Jr.; Pete Crow-Armstrong leads the National League at 105.1, 37.6 ahead of Shohei Ohtani. These are BBMI's final model rankings, not a forecast of the writers' vote.
Yordan Alvarez 71.1 AL · Pete Crow-Armstrong 105.1 NL · final regular seasonOct 12 · 3 minAwards · Cy YoungSchlittler Pulls Clear; Misiorowski and Yamamoto Lead the NL Race
September 16: Cam Schlittler leads the AL runs-saved model at 99.8%. Jacob Misiorowski leads the NL at 57.4%, with Yoshinobu Yamamoto at 37.2% and Chris Sale at 5.4%. Updated inputs, 500 simulated finishes.
Cam Schlittler 99.8% AL · Jacob Misiorowski 57.4% NL · 500 simulated seasonsSep 16 · 4 minSee it live
This is the “we show our work” side. The Prediction Record is the other half — every call locked before the game and graded in public.