All Five Champions Private: Is WIAA Girls Volleyball Fair to Small Schools?
Private schools won all five Wisconsin girls volleyball titles on Nov. 7. From 2017 through 2026, private, charter and Montessori programs were 18% of the Division 4 and 5 brackets, filled 54% of the state tournament spots and won 9 of 13 titles.
BBMI Sports | Girls volleyball, Divisions 4 and 5 | Brackets 2017 through 2026 | Titles 2000 through 2026 | November 8, 2026
Wisconsin’s girls volleyball tournament ended Nov. 7 at the Resch Center in Green Bay, and all five champions were private schools [1]. It is the first volleyball tournament since private schools joined the WIAA in 2000 in which they won every title [2, 4]. In Division 4, all four state teams were private schools: McDonell Catholic, the champion, along with Heritage Christian, Columbus Catholic and Sheboygan Christian. In Division 5, Central Wisconsin Christian won its first title in its first state appearance [1, 5].
Our October article asked whether WIAA basketball gives small schools a fair shot. Readers asked us to run the same analysis for girls volleyball, so this article applies the same tests to volleyball’s two smallest divisions, Divisions 4 and 5. We counted every school in every Division 4 and 5 bracket from 2017 through 2026, every state tournament team and every champion since 2000, from WIAA’s brackets, participation records and championship records [2, 3, 6]. Programs are grouped as in the basketball article: nonboundaried (private, public charter and public Montessori) and other public.
A participating school is any school or co-op team in the Division 4 or 5 tournament bracket in a given season. A school counts once for each season it took part, so a school in all 10 tournaments counts 10 times. Bars show the nonboundaried share of participating schools, state tournament spots (four per division each year) and titles. Ratios compare results per participating school with other public programs; 1.0x means equal results. Sources: WIAA brackets, participation and championship records [2, 3, 6].
From 2017 through 2026, nonboundaried programs were 18% of the participating schools in the Division 4 and 5 tournaments, counting each school once per season. They filled 54% of the state tournament spots and won 9 of the 13 titles. Per participating school, they reached state about 5 times as often as other public programs and won the title about 10 times as often. In basketball’s Divisions 4 and 5, the same comparisons were 2.9 times and 4.2 times. All 28 of the nonboundaried state appearances in Divisions 4 and 5 were by private schools; no charter or Montessori program reached state.
Division 4 has been the most lopsided. Nonboundaried programs were 18% of its schools, filled 20 of its 40 state spots and won 7 of its 10 titles. Division 5, created in 2024, has had three tournaments. Nonboundaried programs filled 8 of its 12 state spots, and in its first year all four state teams were private schools [3].
Division 3 shows a smaller gap. Nonboundaried programs were 17% of its schools, filled 13 of its 40 state spots (33%) and won 4 of its 10 titles. That is about the same as Division 2, so the small-school figures here cover Divisions 4 and 5 only.
| Division | Tournaments | Share of participating schools | Share of state tournament spots | Share of state titles |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Division 3 (for comparison) | 2017-2026 | 17.5% (188 of 1,075) | 32.5% (13 of 40) | 40.0% (4 of 10) |
| Division 4 | 2017-2026 | 18.0% (194 of 1,079) | 50.0% (20 of 40) | 70.0% (7 of 10) |
| Division 5 | 2024-2026 | 17.5% (47 of 269) | 66.7% (8 of 12) | 66.7% (2 of 3) |
| Divisions 4 and 5 | 2017-2026 | 17.9% (241 of 1,348) | 53.8% (28 of 52) | 69.2% (9 of 13) |
Each share is the nonboundaried count divided by the total for that column. Each division sends four teams to state. If every participating team had the same chance of advancing, each group’s share of state spots and titles would be close to its share of participating schools, allowing for year-to-year variation. In Divisions 4 and 5 they are far apart. Until 2024 WIAA volleyball had four divisions, and Division 4 held the smallest quarter of schools, about 120. Since 2024, Divisions 4 and 5 together hold about 180. The La Farge/Youth Initiative co-op, which combines a public and a private school, counts as a participating school in its 9 seasons but in neither group.
Since 2000
The first six Division 4 titles after private schools joined the WIAA, 2000 through 2005, went to public schools. From 2006 through 2026, nonboundaried programs won 17 of 21. By decade, they won 4 of 10 Division 4 titles from 2000 through 2009, 7 of 10 from 2010 through 2019 and 6 of 7 since 2020. In Division 5, which began in 2024, they have won 2 of 3. Division 3 has been closer, at 9 of 27 since 2000. We counted participating schools only from 2017 on, so we cannot say whether the nonboundaried share of the small-school field changed before then.
Each square is one state champion. Columns are tournament years; Division 5 began in 2024. Division 3 is shown for comparison. Won = titles won by nonboundaried programs out of all titles in that division. Every nonboundaried champion in these divisions was a private school. Sources [1, 2].
The small-division titles are concentrated in a few programs. Catholic Central of Burlington won seven Division 4 titles from 2006 through 2020, and Newman Catholic and McDonell Catholic four each. The public champions in those years were Highland (2010), Clayton (2017), Clear Lake (2019) and Wonewoc-Center (2023) in Division 4, and Rib Lake (2025) in Division 5 [2]. School type does not explain every result.
Nonboundaried teams also won more often once they reached state: 9 titles in 28 trips (32%), against 4 in 24 (17%) for other public teams. In basketball’s Divisions 4 and 5, the split was 31% to 21%.
| Outcome | Nonboundaried | Other public | Ratio |
|---|---|---|---|
| Reached state | 11.6 per 100 (28 of 241) | 2.2 per 100 (24 of 1,098) | 5.3x |
| Won the title | 3.7 per 100 (9 of 241) | 0.36 per 100 (4 of 1,098) | 10.3x |
| Won the title, out of that group’s state trips | 32% (9 of 28) | 17% (4 of 24) | 1.9x |
Rate per 100 participating schools = state trips or titles divided by participating schools, times 100. Ratio = nonboundaried rate divided by other public rate; 1.0x means equal results. These are descriptive ratios for these 10 tournaments. The same programs appear year after year, and the title ratio rests on 13 titles. In basketball’s Divisions 4 and 5 the same three ratios were 2.9x, 4.2x and 1.4x (basketball article, Exhibit 2).
The Performance Factor in volleyball
The Performance Factor applies to volleyball as well. Wonewoc-Center, the public district that won the 2023 Division 4 title, reached the six-point trigger in WIAA’s lists for both 2024-25 and 2025-26, as McDonell Catholic did for 2024-25. Wonewoc-Center stayed in its division for 2025-26 through an appeal [7, 8]. As in basketball, the rule counts the same finishes the same way whether a program’s players come from its own district or from a wider area (point 4 in the basketball article).
What volleyball adds
Volleyball gives another reason to look at how Wisconsin groups small schools for the postseason. Across 10 tournaments, nonboundaried programs made up less than a fifth of the Division 4 and 5 field but filled more than half of the state spots and won more than two-thirds of the titles. A few strong programs account for many of those results, and the numbers alone do not explain why the gap exists. But the gap is large enough to question whether enrollment alone is a fair way to place every school. Nothing in the proposal from our basketball article is specific to basketball.
Volleyball data and method. Champions and runners-up 2000-2025 are from WIAA’s championship list, and 2026 results from WIAA’s tournament report and preview [1, 2, 5]. State teams 2000-2025 are from WIAA’s participation list [3]. Participating schools come from every Division 3, 4 and 5 sectional page of WIAA’s 2017-2026 brackets; earlier brackets are not posted in the same form [6]. Across all divisions, our bracket counts match WIAA’s published school totals within three schools in every year from 2017 through 2025 except 2020, a modified tournament with 323 schools in the brackets against 339 in WIAA’s list [2]. The 2020 tournament is included, as the modified 2021 basketball tournament is in the basketball article; WIAA’s separate spring 2021 alternate season is not. Groups follow Appendix A of the basketball article. Charter and Montessori programs took part in these two divisions 4 times and never reached state; counting them as other public changes the ratios to 5.4x for reaching state and 10.5x for winning.
| Year | Division | Champion | Runner-up | Other state teams |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| 2017 | D4 | Clayton | Lourdes Academy (P) | Benton Newman Catholic (P) |
| 2018 | D4 | Catholic Central (P) | Clayton | Newman Catholic (P) River Ridge |
| 2019 | D4 | Clear Lake | Catholic Central (P) | Hillsboro Newman Catholic (P) |
| 2020 | D4 | Catholic Central (P) | McDonell Catholic (P) | Eau Claire Immanuel Lutheran (P) Prentice |
| 2021 | D4 | McDonell Catholic (P) | Wabeno/Laona | Monticello Wonewoc-Center |
| 2022 | D4 | McDonell Catholic (P) | Monticello | Athens Wonewoc-Center |
| 2023 | D4 | Wonewoc-Center | Newman Catholic (P) | Fall River Prentice |
| 2024 | D4 | Manitowoc Lutheran (P) | Regis (P) | Mineral Point Wabeno/Laona |
| 2024 | D5 | Eau Claire Immanuel Lutheran (P) | Columbus Catholic (P) | Newman Catholic (P) Sheboygan Christian (P) |
| 2025 | D4 | Heritage Christian (P) | Regis (P) | Blair-Taylor Montello |
| 2025 | D5 | Rib Lake | Newman Catholic (P) | Florence St. Ambrose (P) |
| 2026 | D4 | McDonell Catholic (P) | Heritage Christian (P) | Columbus Catholic (P) Sheboygan Christian (P) |
| 2026 | D5 | Central Wisconsin Christian (P) | Turtle Lake | Green Bay N.E.W. Lutheran (P) Seneca |
(P) private school, shown in gold. Unmarked schools are other public programs. The 2020 tournament was modified; WIAA’s separate spring 2021 alternate season is not included. Sources [1, 2, 3, 5].
Sources
[1] WIAA, State Girls Volleyball Tournament Produces Five Champions. Nov. 7, 2026. 2026 champions, runners-up and semifinalists.
[2] WIAA, State Girls Volleyball Champions (1973-2025). Champions, runners-up and number of schools by year.
[3] WIAA, Girls State Volleyball Team Participation. Every state tournament appearance by school, through 2025.
[4] WIAA, Editorial: WIAA to Continue Membership Initiatives in 2024-25. Aug. 27, 2024. Membership option for private schools in 2000.
[5] WIAA, 2026 WIAA State Boys & Girls Volleyball Tournament Preview. 2026 state qualifiers and seeds in all five divisions.
[6] WIAA, Girls Volleyball State Archive and tournament brackets, 2017-2026. Sectional bracket pages for each division and year, posted at tournaments.wiaawi.org/brackets/Volleyball/Girls/ by year.
[7] WIAA, Performance Factor Process Results in Divisional Movement. Dec. 14, 2023. Fall programs at six or more points for 2024-25.
[8] WIAA, Performance Factor Update Leads to Additional Fall Divisional Movement. Dec. 5, 2024. Fall promotions and appeals for 2025-26.
Related research
Final 2026 Cy Young Runs-Saved Board: Cam Schlittler and Jacob Misiorowski Finish First
The regular season is complete. Cam Schlittler finishes first in BBMI's American League runs-saved model at 64.7 runs saved, 7.9 ahead of Parker Messick; Jacob Misiorowski leads the National League at 61.2, 5.0 ahead of Yoshinobu Yamamoto. These are BBMI's final model rankings, not a forecast of the writers' vote.
Cam Schlittler 64.7 AL · Jacob Misiorowski 61.2 NL · final regular seasonOct 12 · 3 minAwards · MVPFinal 2026 MVP Value Board: Yordan Alvarez and Pete Crow-Armstrong Finish First
The regular season is complete. Yordan Alvarez finishes first in BBMI's American League value model at 71.1 value runs, 4.2 ahead of Bobby Witt Jr.; Pete Crow-Armstrong leads the National League at 105.1, 37.6 ahead of Shohei Ohtani. These are BBMI's final model rankings, not a forecast of the writers' vote.
Yordan Alvarez 71.1 AL · Pete Crow-Armstrong 105.1 NL · final regular seasonOct 12 · 3 minNCAAF · Power RankingsBBMI NCAAF Power Rankings, Week 3: Georgia Takes No. 1, Texas Lands the First Punch, and Oregon Already Has a Problem
The BBMI Top 25 after three weeks, with every move measured against the September 8 board. Georgia is No. 1 at +37.1, Notre Dame is the model's title favorite at 20%, Texas has beaten the team that started September on top, and Oregon has fallen seven spots after Stillwater.
Georgia +37.1 · Notre Dame 20% title · Utah ▲10 · Oregon ▼7Sep 21 · 12 minSee it live
The live model behind this piece — the same numbers the article is built on.